Is Wave Power Finally Ready to Scale Up?

wave energy power scale up
Carnegie Clean Energy’s CETO 6 device for a wave energy project in Australia. Credit: Carnegie Clean Energy

Technology that can convert ocean waves into electrical power has been around for a while. Wave power projects dot the globe. This form of renewable energy has several key advantages over solar and wind — and yet it hasn’t quite taken off. Experts have an idea why, and how long a scale-up could take.

If wind energy has a graduate degree, wave energy is still in the first grade, Luis Vega, manager of the Hawaii National Marine Renewable Energy Center, recently told NBC News reporter Joseph Bennington-Castro. Vega and others in the field are testing a wave energy converter called the Bolt Lifesaver.

Besides the Bolt Lifesaver, other projects abound — with technologies that look drastically different. There is Carnegie Clean Energy’s balloon-like CETO technology in Australia as well as snake-like wave energy converters being developed by Wave Energy Scotland. So far, no one wave converter design has risen to the top.

R&D continues. Earlier this year, US senators backed a bill to reauthorize wave power research. The DOE’s Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy pointed out today that the Water Power Technologies Office is funding early-stage research on “new, transformative [pumped-storage hydropower] designs that would improve sustainability and environmental performance and shorten development timeframes for new facilities.”

Wave power has advantages over wind and solar such as predictability and the ability to harness the waves 24-7, Bennington-Castro reported. Energy density is also an advantage. “Every meter of the California coast receives 30 kilowatts of wave energy” while “every square meter of a solar panel receives 0.2 to 0.3 kilowatts of solar energy.”

But there are major hurdles as well. They include engineering for a challenging, sometimes violent marine environment, according to Bennington-Castro. Deployment requires costly vessels and divers, too. In 2014, a wave energy project off the coast of Victoria, Australia, that was supposed to be the “world’s largest” was abandoned due to lack of commercial viability.

Public resistance is another factor. Several years ago, a wave energy project in Oregon was shut down by an opposition group claiming it would jeopardize ocean recreation, public safety, and the environment.

Experts told Bennington-Castro that developing wave converters that marry efficiency and economy could take a decade. Vega told the reporter that the timing depends on how much funding goes into developing the technology. Another expert said that, realistically, wave energy will ultimately only contribute about 6% of the total electricity in the United States, similar to hydropower.

We are accepting submissions for the 2018 Energy Manager Today Product and Project Awards. The final deadline is December 15, 2017. Learn more here.

Packaging LED & Advanced Rooftop Unit Control (ARC) Retrofits for Maximum Performance
Sponsored By: Transformative Wave

  
Choosing the Correct Emission Control Technology
Sponsored By: Anguil Environmental Systems

  
Planning for a Sustainable Future
Sponsored By: Dakota Software

  
The New Energy Future - Challenges and Opportunities in Corporate Energy Management
Sponsored By: Edison Energy

  

2 thoughts on “Is Wave Power Finally Ready to Scale Up?

  1. What about the AquaHarmonics device that won the DOE’s contest to find technologies that at least double current capabilities? The DOE claimed that this device greatly exceeded that goal (and achieved a 5 fold improvement). So, why isn’t everyone pursuing that technology now, instead of all the others? The DOE clearly indicated that it was a game-changer and the one to beat in the future. Why wasn’t it even mentioned here? Was the DOE lying? Who’s telling the truth? I don’t understand what’s going on in wave energy. Everyone is claiming they have the solution. Why is it OK to make such claims and confuse potential investors?

  2. You’re right. It is confusing. There are so many different competing wave power technologies in development right now that it’s impossible to say which will become the standard. The DOE wants to see what’s actually going to work so they’re encouraging different approaches. AquaHarmonics received $1.5M so they can create a bigger version to test in the ocean. Portland Business Journal reported that the design period is 18 months, so we just have to wait and see how it goes.

Leave a Comment

User Name :
Password :
 
If you've no account register here first time
User Name :
User Email :
Password :

Login Now